|
Sept. 9, 2011
Research into practice
Dogs put their nose to the job of fighting cancer.
SHERI SHEFA CANADIAN JEWISH NEWS
According to veterinary student and Toronto native Rachel Wallach, studies have proven that dogs can smell cancer in humans and scientists should switch their focus to putting the discovery into practice.
“All the research has gone into ‘Can they?’ The answer is yes. They can absolutely smell these disease markers,” said Wallach, an Anne and Max Tanenbaum Community Hebrew Academy of Toronto graduate and third-year University of Glasgow veterinary student.
A study carried out by German researchers and published in the European Respiratory Journal recently showed that dogs were able to detect lung tumors in 71 percent of patients. Wallach explained that the researchers trained dogs to detect “volatile organic compounds,” which are linked to the presence of cancer, using their keen sense of smell.
“There is actually no human contact with the dogs.... Patients who had lung cancer, [as well as] patients from a control group who were healthy, had to breathe into a tube with a cotton swab at the bottom and then it was sealed,” Wallach said. “Dogs were trained to positively ID based on reward, the ones with cancer. After they were put through rigorous training protocol, they were given a blind sample and it was a double blind, so even the handler didn’t know which were positive and which were negative.”
The results from this study showed that the dogs identified 71 lung cancer samples out of 100. “Now that we know that they can, how do we move forward and use it to our advantage?” she asked.
Wallach, who spent her summer in Toronto and has been doing clinical rotations at several practices in the city, said she became fascinated with the work being done in this field. “There is something magical about the fact that dogs can do that,” she said.
After learning about a summer research program offered by her school, Wallach obtained a grant to do a literature review on cancer-sniffing dogs.
“In the last decade or so, there has been research about whether dogs can smell disease, whether it is cancer or diabetes or even parasitic infections,” she said. However, she added, despite the number of similar studies, there is no consistent training method for the dogs.
“There is no system that exists in the research sector. There is no protocol on how to train these dogs. I think, in order for the research to continue, you have to have a base method of training and evaluation. If you evaluate one way, and another lab evaluates another way, you’re comparing apples to oranges,” Wallach said. “What I’m looking to do is to compare the dogs that have been trained for these projects with the dogs that have been trained ... [to detect] explosives and drugs. I’m comparing the ways in which these dogs have been trained and used and evaluated.”
Wallach said she is also polling opinions about the studies because many researchers say that, although the results are remarkable, they don’t see how these dogs can be used in practice. If this hurdle can be overcome and researchers can find a way to put this theory into practice, however, the method could serve as a way to detect cancer earlier than can some medical tests.
“The dogs are so amazing at early diagnosis that they are able to detect it before a patient even has symptoms or before a doctor even says ‘I think I’d like to test for something,’” Wallach noted.
She said that, in one of the first cancer-sniffing dog studies, dogs were trained to detect prostate cancer in patients’ urine. “All but four dogs kept identifying this one urine sample from a control patient who was supposed to be a healthy patient, so the researchers were concerned enough to let the person know. Further tests were done and it turned out that the person had a kidney tumor.”
Wallach said there are similar stories from other studies. “When something sets off the dogs’ radar,” she said, “I think people have been concerned enough to say, ‘OK, let’s look into that.’”
For more national Jewish news, visit cjnews.com.
^TOP
|
