The Western Jewish Bulletin about uscontact ussearch
Shalom Dancers Dome of the Rock Street in Israel Graffiti Jewish Community Center Kids Wailing Wall
Serving British Columbia Since 1930
homethis week's storiesarchivescommunity calendarsubscribe
 


home > this week's story

 

special online features
faq
about judaism
business & community directory
vancouver tourism tips
links

Sign up for our e-mail newsletter. Enter your e-mail address here:

Search the JWB web site:


 

 

archives

Dec. 16, 2005

B'nai Brith goes north

Delegation visits Manitoba First Nations.
MATT BELLAN JEWISH POST AND NEWS

For Alan Yusim, the most vivid memory of the day was seeing the living conditions. For Rabbi Alan Green, it was learning how people prevail in such "harsh" situations.

Yusim, Green and four others took part in a precedent-setting B'nai Brith Canada visit to two northern Manitoba First Nations communities last month.

The group had received a personal invitation from Grand Chief Arnold Ouskan of the Keewatin Tribal Council and Grand Chief Dr. Sydney Garrioch of Manitoba Keewatinook Ininew Okimowin.

The one-day trip to Oxford House and Tadoule Lake followed years of relationship-building between his organization and First Nations communities, Yusim noted.

The contacts started several years ago, but increased after David Ahenakew, a one-time national First Nations leader, made anti-Semitic comments at a public First Nations gathering in Saskatoon in December 2002. Over the past three summers, B'nai Brith has helped arrange a series of First Nations clergy, educators and leaders missions to Israel. Rev. Raymond McLean, pastor of the Winnipeg-based Southeast Aboriginal Ministries, played a leading role in organizing the trips.

"While in Israel, we met with Israeli government officials and NGO (nongovernmental organizations) experts," said Yusim, who accompanied First Nations leaders on a summer 2005 trip.

"They joined us in talks with First Nations leaders on economic development, infrastructure building and combatting poverty, based on the Israeli experience."

The Nov. 10 trip to Tadoule Lake, west of Churchill, and Oxford House, at the northern end of Lake Winnipeg, included Ronen Gil-Or, deputy head of missions of the Israeli embassy in Ottawa, and Winnipeg-born Vivian Silver, executive director of the Negev Institute for Strategies of Peace and Development in Be'er Sheva.

"Each First Nations community has its own needs and is in a unique position for opportunity," said Yusim. "Tadoule Lake may be a location appropriate for eco-tourism and for some sort of water purification technology."

Of 100 homes in the community, only 35 per cent have running water. Enormous diesel generators supply power, but a community centre, nursing station and other facilities have all been added since the generators started operating, overloading the power supply.

"One of the homes we visited had no running water," Yusim recalled. "They had a fridge and stove, but no available amps to operate them. They had to use a hot plate."

Oxford House, on the other hand, sits on "abundant" resources such as diamond deposits. In fact, said Yusim, the federal government has licensed companies from Japan and Germany to mine those resources.

"The local people haven't been brought in," he said. "By policy, they're not allowed to develop their own resources."

Current plans are for representatives of some Israeli-based NGOs to visit Oxford House and Tadoule Lake and conduct a formal needs assessment in each community. First Nations leaders might also visit the Negev Institute, to study techniques developed there for water purification and land reclamation.

"It will be similar in some ways to work the institute has done with Bedouins in Israel," said Yusim.

Green, who is the rabbi of Shaarey Zedek Synagogue, Winnipeg's biggest congregation, has also been involved in aboriginal projects in the city, Yusim said. Organizers thought it would be appropriate for residents of Tadoule Lake and Oxford House to meet "a Jewish spiritual leader." Green, guest of the Keewatin Tribal Council and Manitoba Keewatinook Ininew Okimowin on the trip, answered questions about Judaism during meetings with local residents and leaders. Green said he found the two communities not only isolated, but "beautiful" in their isolation.

"The air is extremely clean," he observed. "I was aware of a spiritual feeling in the communities we visited ... I think there's much we can learn from them in terms of prevailing under harsh conditions. They have reserves of patience, energy and frugality, and a willingness to overcome obstacles. As much as we can help them materially, they can help us spiritually."

As for Yusim, his most vivid impression of the trip is that "here in Canada, there are entire communities that have been denied ... the right to have their basic needs met. It's appalling that this can be happening in Canada."

Frank Dimant, executive vice-president of B'nai Brith Canada and another participant on the one-day trip, was singled out for special honors. Ouskan announced a special ceremony at Oxford House next February to install Dimant as an honorary First Nations chief.

"This is the first time that we are bestowing such honor on one of Canada's foremost Jewish community leaders, in recognition of B'nai Brith Canada's outstanding efforts to strengthen the ties between Jewish and aboriginal peoples," Ouskan said. "We are also grateful to B'nai Brith for bringing the plight of the First Nations communities to the attention of the public."

^TOP